Delicious 2025 Copycat Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake

Craving for warm memories of Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake ice cream, but don’t find it at your nearest shop? Here is a great copycat recipe that takes you all back to the good old days of the birthday celebration with each spoonful, creamy flavorful cake base complemented with chunks of moist yellow cake and swirling frosting filled with colorful confetti sprinkles. 

It will guide you through the recreation of each step toward making this now-iconic flavor: from baking the cake from scratch to making a rich ice cream base and preparing the bright frosting swirl. And whether it is going to be served at a party or just for the self-indulgence sense of enjoyment, indeed, a recipe like this will promise to bring with it an experience sweet and pleasing.

How to Make Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake?

This ice cream flavor involves three things: a smooth and creamy vanilla ice cream base, tiny chunks of yellow cake, and a swirl of sweet confetti frosting. Making the ice cream base in an ice cream machine starts first. While that churns, a simple cake would be baked, and an ultra-rich frosting made. During the final assembly-that’s where the real magic happens-melting-soft ice cream is layered with crumbled bits of cake and frosting for a flavor and textural crescendo!

Key Ingredients

• 2 cups heavy cream
• 1¼ cups whole milk (2 tbsp reserved for frosting)
• 1¼ cups granulated sugar (¾ cup for base, ½ cup for cake)
• ¼ cup unsalted butter, softened (plus 2 tbsp for frosting)
• 1 egg
• 1 cup all-purpose flour
• ½ tsp baking powder
• 2 tsp vanilla extract (1 tbsp for base, ½ tsp each for cake & frosting)
• Pinch of salt
• 1 cup powdered sugar
• Rainbow sprinkles

Instructions

1. Prepare the Ice Cream Base

Set out a large bowl and whisk the cream with whole milk, sugar, vanilla extract, and salt until the sugar dissolves. Pour the mixture into an ice cream maker and churn according to the manufacturer’s instructions until it is a soft serve. This rich and creamy base lets the flavors of the cake and frosting shine through.  

2. Bake the Yellow Cake Pieces

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C) with a small cookie sheet lined with parchment. In a bowl, sift flour along with sugar, then mix in butter, egg, milk, vanilla extract, baking powder, and salt. Pour the batter evenly onto the baking pan. Bake for about 15-20 minutes, until a toothpick comes out clean. These crumbs, soft and golden, give that classic birthday cake feel to the ice cream once cool and crumbled into pieces smaller than pea-size.

3. Make the Confetti Frosting Swirl

In another bowl, a hand mixer or a whisk is used to combine the powdering sugar, softened butter, milk, and vanilla for a smooth and spreadable consistency. Fold in the rainbow sprinkles for a confetti touch. The bright swirl will sweeten every scoop and is just adorbs.

4. Layer and Assemble the Ice Cream

After it has softened, pour one-half of this mixture into a container that can go into the freezer. Put one layer of crumbled pieces of cake on top; drizzle half of the frosting on it; pour the remaining ice cream over it. Top with more pieces of cake and the remaining frosting. This is how you build your layers so that every bite will have the ideal blend of cake, frosting, and creamy base.

5. Swirl and Freeze

The cake pieces and frosting should be swirled through the ice cream slightly using a knife or spatula to create a marbled effect. Do cover the container and freeze for several hours till ice cream is set and ready to scoop. Letting it set completely will give you that extra, beautifully rich scoopable texture as it’s meant to be. Once frozen, scoop the marbled ice cream into bowls or cones for serving. Garnish with extra sprinkles or small cake crumbs for a festive touch.

Tips for a Perfect Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake

• The machine works on the ice-cream freezing principle, preventing the formation of large ice crystals for smoothest texture. 
• Cool cake bits thoroughly before folding them into the ice cream, or they might melt it. 
• Overmixing will ruin the lovely marbled effect; fold slowly and gently to maintain aesthetics. 
• Sprinkles should go in at the last possible moment in the swirl to prevent them from melting away.

What to Serve With

1. A Slice of Birthday Cake

The ultimate classic would be a birthday cake slice with Baskin Robbins Icing on the cake Ice Cream on the Cake flavor. The light vanilla sponge cake with real buttercream layers enhances the nostalgic experience of this nice cake-flavored creamy ice cream. Together, they each taste like a birthday memory. Store-bought? Homemade? Two desserts multiplied the fun, and every deserved taste of cake ice cream felt like an occasion. 

2. Warm Fudgy Brownies

This is a match that will hardly be beaten. Cold ice cream meets warm brownies in a real velvety treat that brings together flavors and textures from one end of the spectrum to the other: cold, creamy and rich, dense, chewy. The chocolatey richness balances the sweetness of the frosting swirl so every spoonful feels like a guilty indulgence. A pairing of desserts that call loudly to anyone loving anything chocolate, compounded layers of textures or flavors in their desserts.

3. Waffle Cone or Bowl

For all the true ice cream shops that are nostalgic and lovable, it is a must that they serve Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake ice cream in a hot waffle cone (or bowl). The crunchy, buttery freshness of the cone offers texture to the lightly toasted flavor, even as it complements the sweetness of cake-flavored ice cream. Every single mouthful is an amalgamation of lusciousness, crunch, and buttery essence-upon-essence in the whole experience. Simple yet really rich, and it will forever score on crowd-pleasing.

4. As an Affogato

You take a scoop of Icing on the Cake ice cream and pour over it a shot of hot espresso as you watch the ice cream melt into a beautiful coffee dessert. And the bitterness of the espresso really cuts into the sweetness of the cake base and the frosting swirl, which makes the combination just brilliant. It is absolutely an adult twist on what would feel like childhood, but still a really awesome way to indulge in coffee and any kind of odd yet wonderful dessert pairings. 

5. With Fresh Strawberries

Fresh Strawberries-well worth the effort. That tanginess tames the sweetness of the cake and frosting back into balance. Slice up some strawberries and set them off with-side or on top of-the ice cream for just a touch more brightness. Pretty, too! Your dessert will be a visual treat to match the taste-just right for summer or bright fruity fun. 

6. Sandwiched Between Cookies

That ice cream, Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake , can be used to form a fabulous treat if the ice cream is sandwiched in between two cookies. Soft sugar cookies or chewy chocolate chips are preferred; they bring a perfect chewy, creamy, crunchy balance. As the ice cream melts just a bit and gets absorbed by the cookie layers with every bite, the indulgence builds. So not only is it good, but it’s also completely portable-a fun dessert for parties, picnics, or family nights.

Ingredients substitutes

1. Non-Dairy Ice Cream Base

Isn’t it amazing? Just make some quick adaptations to the Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake for the lactose intolerant or dairy-dodging desserts. Instead of heavy cream and whole milk, use full-fat coconut milk blended with some almond milk and you get the same creamy texture. Of course, agave syrup or maple syrup would take the granulated “sugar” right out into the real all-natural, light-filled realm. Such marvelous, rich-flavored bases leave you assured of absolutely dairy-free enjoyment for all. 

2. Gluten-Free Cake Pieces

In fact, if you are concerned about gluten, you can bake those cake pieces with this recipe using some gluten-free cake mix from a store or using a homemade recipe with a blend of gluten-free flours. These make you have that same soft, moist texture but render the dessert safe to consume for people who are gluten sensitive. The flavor is just as delicious and no one will ever notice the difference. It’s easy as that and everyone gets to enjoy the party in this ice cream.

3. Vegan-Friendly Version

To prepare Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake Ice cream in a totally vegan format, you will replace both the dairy as well as the eggs in the recipe. First, a recipe needs to be found for a vegan cake, wherein the pieces of cake will be made, and then plant-based butter and non-dairy milk should be used as substitutes for frosting, exquisitely topped with vegan-certified sprinkles. The base should then consist of coconut milk with another plant-based alternative such as oat milk or soy milk. Thus, Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake ice cream will be absolutely fun and indulgent without losing out on flavors in being 100 percent vegan. 

4. Reduced-Sugar Frosting

It will be a frosting just enough for those with enough room to breathe and enjoy this Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake . In such an event, where sweetness or even flavor is sacrificed, I will leave you with the trace sweet alternative to powdered sugar: monk fruit sweetener, erythritol, or stevia. Oh, if you rather like creams, this really seals the mold, though Greek yogurt puts it into the base, contouring the flavor with tang while cutting down on the sweeter side of overall sugar-added frosting and thus in every aspect making it light, fit, and guiltless.

5. Nut-Free Adjustments

Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake recipe can also be changed to adapt it to nut-allergy worries while keeping its sweet and textural integrity. Replace the almond milk with oat milk, soy milk, or rice milk for the non-dairy base. Combine oat milk and coconut cream for additional richness while trying to achieve a creaminess like that of the dairy. Read the labels on sprinkles and all other decorating toppings; some brands contain traces of nut ingredients. All these modifications make it allergy friendly and safe for everyone.

Nutritional Facts

Final Thoughts

Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake Ice cream creation is a little more than some simple comfort food. It is a well-tested homemade recipe for icing in the past, and like in Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake , this recipe serves to deliver possibly the most cherished flavor right inside your kitchen so you can take complete control of the ingredients used and quality. Certainly worth all the celebrations, rich and creamy with cake flavor, swirled in it with pieces of soft cake and sweet confetti frosting-happy treat, indeed. 

Celebrate the darkest situations, for in the moment, cake and ice cream serve to pull anyone’s mood out of a slump! Get the ingredients together and ice cream-maker: you are about to recreate the flavor that will carry memorable flashes through your happiest birthday times by making Baskin Robbins Icing on the Cake Ice cream.

Craving more? Check out the recipe for Cotton Candy Blizzard and explore more delicious treat recipes here.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)